An understated Hamptons sitting room with a linen sofa, walnut table and tall window overlooking a private late-autumn garden.

Where Sag Harbor's 2026 Home Sales Caught Up With Southampton Village's

In October, 27east reported the $12.2 million sale of Residence B at 2 West Water Street in Sag Harbor. The 11,723-square-foot townhouse was built in 2023 and is one of three homes in a waterfront development on Sag Harbor Cove. It has 250 feet of cove frontage and two 60-foot slips in a deep-water marina. It was last asking $15.5 million. Zach Tunick of Douglas Elliman, who brought the buyer, told 27east the buyer "wanted to be on the water, have access to his boat and still be able to walk into Sag Harbor for dinner."

A $12 million house you can walk home from after dinner is the kind of sale people associate with Southampton Village. Through September 2026, Sag Harbor Village sold close to as many houses as Southampton Village at every level between $2 million and $10 million, and the two villages part ways only at the very top.

Two Villages, One Median, Opposite Directions

Brown Harris Stevens' third-quarter 2026 Hamptons report covers single-family homes. It puts the median sale price for both Sag Harbor Village and Southampton Village at exactly $4,150,000 for July through September 2026.

The two villages got to that number from opposite directions. In Sag Harbor Village, third-quarter sales rose to 23 from 17 a year earlier, and the median climbed from $2,650,000. Eleven of those 23 sales landed between $3 million and $5 million, compared with two in the third quarter of 2025. In Southampton Village, third-quarter sales fell to 20 from 30. The median slipped from $4,392,500, and the average dropped to $6,366,750 from $8,176,322. The village closed four sales above $10 million that quarter, half as many as the eight it closed in the third quarter of 2025.

The same report says the wider Sag Harbor area did more than $285 million in third-quarter 2026 transactions, the most of any area it tracks. The Southampton area did $270 million.

The Hamptons Market Behind Both Villages

Across the Hamptons, the $3 million to $5 million band was the only price category that grew in the third quarter of 2026. Brown Harris Stevens counted a 17.2% year-over-year gain there. Over the same period, sales above $10 million fell 29.6% and total sales fell 15.8% to 347. Supply is also tight. Long Island Business News reported 973 Hamptons listings at the end of September 2026, down 22.5% from 1,256 a year earlier.

Appraiser Jonathan Miller's third-quarter analysis on Housing Notes uses a different method. It puts the overall Hamptons median at $1,875,000, down 6.3% year over year, with the $1 million to $5 million range accounting for 65.5% of third-quarter sales. Miller attributes the lower figure to fewer high-end closings rather than broad price declines. In the third quarter of 2026, Hamptons activity moved into the middle of the market and away from the top. We wrote in September about how a shift in the mix of homes selling can move a Hamptons median without any one house changing in value. The village-level numbers below show the same effect.

Counting Houses Instead of Medians

A quarterly median in a village with 14 to 23 sales is a fragile number. Sag Harbor Village's median was $4,250,000 in the first quarter of 2026, fell to $2,662,500 in the second quarter, and came back to $4,150,000 in the third. Southampton Village went from $8,400,000 in the first quarter to $4,275,000 in the second. A handful of large closings landing in one quarter or the next is enough to move these medians.

A count of sales in each price band is steadier. The table below adds up the Brown Harris Stevens single-family price-band columns for the first three quarters of 2026. The firm marks its first- and second-quarter figures as preliminary.

Price band, 1Q–3Q 2026 Sag Harbor Village sales Southampton Village sales
Under $1 million 0 2
$1 million to $2 million 12 6
$2 million to $3 million 8 7
$3 million to $5 million 20 17
$5 million to $10 million 12 11
Above $10 million 1 14
Total 53 57

Between $2 million and $10 million, the two villages traded almost the same number of houses through September 2026: 40 in Sag Harbor Village and 35 in Southampton Village. Above $10 million they split, with 14 sales in Southampton Village against one in Sag Harbor Village.

Sag Harbor Village has also already caught up with its own recent past. It closed 53 single-family sales in the first nine months of 2026, compared with 75 for all of 2025, when its full-year median was $2,750,000. Its 2026 sales came mostly from the $3 million to $10 million range, which accounted for 32 of the 53.

Where the Villages Actually Part

For a buyer budgeting between $3 million and $10 million, these two villages are close to one market. Each closed roughly the same number of houses in that range in 2026, which suggests similar depth of inventory and similar competition for well-priced homes. In a 2026 broker roundtable, 27east reported that brokers described the under-$5 million segment as particularly strong and move-in-ready homes as the most contested.

Above $10 million, Southampton Village is the deeper market of the two. Seven of its 17 first-quarter sales cleared that level, which explains the $8.4 million median for those three months. Its average sale price stays well above Sag Harbor Village's even in quarters when the medians match: $6,366,750 against $4,644,348 in the third quarter of 2026. Southampton Village's higher reputation comes from its top tier, and the 2026 counts show the two villages much closer once that tier is set aside.

This affects comparable sales. A Sag Harbor Village seller above $10 million has very few in-village comps from 2026 and will be priced against waterfront and new-construction sales like 2 West Water Street, where the final price came in under the last ask. A buyer who is priced out of Southampton Village between $3 million and $5 million will find similar depth and similar prices in Sag Harbor Village.

What Each Village Is Building This Winter

Both villages are investing in their walkable cores this winter.

In Sag Harbor, the Village set November 10, 2026, as the start of staging for a new waterfront boardwalk, with completion due by April 1, 2027. The Sag Harbor Express on 27east reports that the boardwalk runs from Windmill Beach, under the bridge, to Steinbeck Park Beach. The 20-slip municipal "A" Dock at 11 West Water Street, just west of The Beacon, is being replaced at the same time with a floating dock, a new bulkhead, and a new boardwalk and catwalk. The dock had not been upgraded since the 1970s. The Village's goal is to open both projects before Memorial Day. The Sag Harbor Partnership has committed $250,000 toward the boardwalk, and landscape architect Ed Hollander is coordinating the preparatory work pro bono. Through the winter, the Village expects equipment staged near "A" Dock and possible temporary parking restrictions around the marina.

In Southampton Village, Mayor William M. Manger Jr. wrote in the Village's Fall 2026 newsletter that 2026 was the village's busiest summer, with the U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club and the sesquicentennial parade drawing crowds. He also reported:

  • the Moses Park playground and walking trails are essentially complete, paid for by the park fee from the Village Latch development on Hill Street
  • a new garden, fountains and amphitheater at the Southampton Arts Center, given by Alina and John Paulson, have been popular
  • a brick-paved pedestrian walkway is planned north of Hildreth's on Main Street
  • a dog park is planned on the lot next to Rogers Memorial Library

The Parade of Lights and the Christmas tree lighting are on Saturday, November 28. On Jobs Lane, Fēniks opened in September 2025 at 75 Jobs Lane, the former Le Chef space, which Long Island Business News reported had closed after 40 years.

Questions We Hear on This Comparison

Is Sag Harbor Village now as expensive as Southampton Village? Between $2 million and $10 million, the 2026 sales counts are close enough to treat the two as one market. Above $10 million, Southampton Village had 14 single-family sales in the first three quarters of 2026 and Sag Harbor Village had one, so the top of the market still sits mostly in Southampton Village.

Will Sag Harbor Village's median hold at $4 million or more? The quarterly series is too uneven to say. The median went from $4.25 million in the first quarter of 2026 to $2.66 million in the second and back to $4.15 million in the third, on 14 to 23 sales a quarter. The more reliable 2026 signal is the number of sales between $3 million and $5 million: 20 through September, more than in any other band.

Does the Hamptons-wide median tell me much about either village? Not much. In the third quarter of 2026, Brown Harris Stevens put the Hamptons median at $2.2 million and Jonathan Miller put it at $1.875 million. Both villages sold at roughly double either figure. The village and price-band tables tell you more. See our Hamptons neighborhood overview for the hamlets around these two villages.

If you are weighing Sag Harbor Village against Southampton Village, The Michael Graves Team can go through the 2026 sales in your price band in both villages with you before you choose. Schedule a private consultation.

Work With Us

The Michael Graves Team combines market expertise, innovative strategies, and personalized service to deliver exceptional results. From luxury properties to investment opportunities, we ensure your experience is smooth & successful.

Follow Me on Instagram